After much drama leading to this year’s open enrollment for Affordable Care Act coverage—a shorter time frame, a sharply reduced federal budget for marketing and assistance, and confusion resulting from months of repeal-and-replace debate —the final tally paints a mixed picture.
With all states now reporting, ACA plan enrollment ticked downward this year, a report out Wednesday shows, but states running their own marketplaces saw slight gains and did better than those relying on the federal exchange.
About 11.8 million Americans enrolled in 2018 coverage, down 3.7 percent from last year’s total, according to the National Academy for State Health Policy. California, which has the nation’s largest state market with about 1.5 million enrollees, saw a 2.3 percent drop in overall sign-ups, even though it had an enrollment period six weeks longer than the federal marketplace.
Covered California Director Peter Lee attributed some of that to efforts by the state to encourage off-market purchases by consumers who don’t qualify for subsidies.
All told, enrollment in marketplaces fully or partially run by states showed a small overall increase of 0.2 percent over the previous year, while the 34 states that rely entirely on the federal hub saw sign-ups drop by 5.3 percent, the report said.
Open enrollment began shortly after the Trump administration sharply cut federal enrollment outreach efforts and ended a type of cost-sharing subsidy paid directly to insurers, which generally responded by raising premiums to make up for the loss.
“Despite all that, enrollment in the marketplaces across the nation was remarkably stable,” said Trish Riley, executive director of the academy, a nonprofit, non-partisan group.
Officials from states operating their own exchanges said their ability to make changes led to their gains.
“We could extend our open-enrollment period, control our marketing budget and nimbly mitigate the impact of the loss of cost-sharing subsidies [to insurers], which led to a very successful open enrollment,” said Zachary Sherman, director of Rhode Island’s state-run market.
Enrollment there is up 12 percent this year, he said, with sharp increases in the number of newly enrolled and policyholders aged 18 to 34.
Marketplace plans were more expensive than those sold outside healthcare.gov for unsubsidized consumers because California and other states asked insurers to load the premium increases stemming from Trump administration directives onto on-market plans. Those on-market price hikes were largely offset by jumps in tax credits for consumers receiving subsidies.
Despite their upbeat tone about this year’s enrollment, directors of several state marketplaces warned that 2019 looks grim.
“Just the removal of the individual mandate penalty in Congress’ recently enacted tax overhaul] will mean premiums go up 15 percent to 30 percent or more depending on the state,” said Lee.
People who get subsidies will be largely shielded from those increases because the subsidies rise along with the premiums.