Counting the Cost
White women can’t speak for me, so I will support the women’s march
Julianne Malveaux | 1/12/2017, midnight
“Ain’t I A Woman,” railed Sojourner Truth, “I have ploughed and planted and gathered into barns, and no man could head me! And ain’t I a woman! I could work as much and eat as much as a man—when I could get it—and bear the lash as well. And ain’t I a woman? I’ve bourne 13 children and seen most all sold off and when I cried out with my mother’s grief, none but Jesus heard me! And ain’t I a woman.”
The similarities and differences between Black and White women are captured in Sojourner Truth’s famous December 1851 speech. She movingly talks about the men who say women should be “helped into carriages, and moved over ditches, and have the best place everywhere,” while “nobody ever helps me into carriages or over mud puddles, or gives me any best place.” Both Black and White women cry a mother’s grief for the loss of a child, and both endure labor pains. Black women’s lives, while similar, are different and often disadvantaged because they lack the privilege that White women so easily take for granted and often fail to notice or remedy.
Thus, it did not surprise me that a White woman in Hawaii called for a “Million Women’s March” on Washington on the day after the presidential inauguration. And it did not surprise me when White women took up the call. Too bad these same White women did not advocate more forcefully against the man who won the Electoral College vote for the presidency.
My first inclination was to ignore this women’s march. The organizers have repeatedly struck me as tone deaf and indifferent to the diverse needs of women. But when I talked to Tamika Mallory, the dynamic young woman activist who was once executive director of Rev. Al Sharpton’s National Action Network, I shifted my perspective. Mallory shared that, just a few days after the initial call to march was issued, organizers reached out to her asking for help. She said they said they "needed to ensure that women of color were involved."
Now, there are four co-chairs of the Women’s March on Washington, including African American leader Mallory, Latina activist and part of Harry Belafonte’s Gathering for Justice, Carmen Perez, a White woman entrepreneur whose T-shirts have been galvanizing, Bob Bland, and Palestinian activist Linda Sarsour. I applaud the diversity in leadership, but wonder how many women of color will turn out on Jan. 21. Tens of thousands of women from all over the country are expected, with more than 100,000 saying they plan to be there. But many African American women have looked askance, perhaps with distaste from the cultural appropriation of the initial organizing descriptive, “Million Women’s March,” perhaps because we recoil from the strong support White women gave the president-elect, choosing race loyalty over gender, class, or personal interest.
I applaud Mallory. She told me “I was not willing to let this convening come together without having Black women involved.” In other words, White women cannot speak for all women. If White women had their way, the march and rally would probably focus only on equal pay and reproductive rights. Thanks to Tamika and her colleagues, a statement of principles, to be issued next week, will also address racial justice, police brutality, criminal justice reform and mass incarceration.