Proposition 28 changes rather than reduces term limits

Email Print Twitter Facebook MySpace Stumble Digg More Destinations
Shae Collins  |   OW College Intern

Some claim legislators will have too much power

The wording of Proposition 28 is tricky. The information in the official voter guide says that Prop. 28 reduces the total amount of time a person may serve as a state legislator from 14 years to 12 years. Supporters of this measure argue that Prop. 28 places a definite 12-year limit on legislators. 

But those against the measure say that it actually weakens term limits and lengthens a legislator’s time in office.

To understand the change, voters must know the existing term limits in the Assembly and the Senate. Currently, a legislator can serve a total of 14 years: two four-year terms, or a total of eight years in the Senate, and three, two-year terms, or a total of six years in the Assembly. 

However, legislators can also fill vacancies, which equate to partial terms as long as they are fewer than one half of a term. These vacancies are not included in their term limits, and can add up to nearly 17 years in office. 

Prop. 28 does reduce the terms legislators can serve from 14 to 12 years, and gets rid of what supporters of the measure call “the 17-year loophole” by making limits of time in office based on years instead of terms. However, it increases the number of years a legislator can serve in one chamber from eight years in the senate or six years in the Assembly to 12 years in either or both houses. According to Michael Shires, Ph.D., a professor at Pepperdine University School of Public Policy, if this measure passes, voters will see names that stay on the ballot longer, strengthening incumbency. 

There has been some confusion about whether or not Prop. 28 benefits current legislators. Those opposed to the measure fear Prop. 28 allows current legislators who are reelected, which is potentially about 80 percent of them, to receive the extended term limits added on to the time they have already been in office. However, the wording of the measure ensures that the changed term limits only affect first-time elected officials. Legislators currently in office remain under the existing term limits. 

Supporters of the measure believe that the extension to 12 years will positively impact politics in Sacramento. They argue that with Prop. 28, there will fewer legislators starting from zero and learning the job of being a legislator from the beginning every few years.

Gabriel Sanchez, a spokesperson for Californians for a Fresh Start, a coalition in support of the measure, explains that with Prop. 28, legislators will stay in office longer, gain more experience, and have the expertise needed to do their jobs better. He says that “[Prop 28] makes term limits more effective.”

Those against the measure, including Californians for Term Limits, believe that Prop. 28 is a sham that deceives voters into thinking that term limits are reduced, when they are lengthened in one chamber. Those opposed believe that Prop. 28 gives legislators too much power.

Related Articles

  • Helping women stay strong -

    As National Women’s Health Week neared its end, several local healthcare providers and community groups sponsored informative and healthful activities for area residents looking to maintain good physical well being and to learn about preventive measures.

  • Long Beach colleges: cuts to Black Studies and vocational classes -

    The ongoing budget crisis in California has necessitated major academic reform on every level of education to save money and eliminate debt. As a result, some schools have been forced to lay off faculty, eliminate various courses, scale back on financial aid, and retool curriculum guidelines.

    Recently, two separate protest rallies led by the students and faculty of Long Beach State (CSULB), and Long Beach City College (LBCC), were held in response to proposed cuts of various class offerings and academic programs.

  • The immigration dream -

    A 2013 bipartisan poll from the Democratic Hart Research firm and the Republican Public Opinion Strategies firm shows that 77 percent of American voters feel immigration reform is good for the United States.

    One study, conducted by the Center for the Study of Immigration at the University of Southern California, shows that if the estimated 8.5 million lawful permanent residents became U.S. citizens, their earnings alone over the next decade would generate somewhere between $21 to $45 billion.

  • Following the star -

    One of the more memorable images in the Bible is that of the journey made by the wise men to Bethlehem. When portrayed in school Christmas plays, this scene usually signals the play’s finale.

  • Kamala D. Harris: in search of justice -

    After winning what was described as a “razor close” election for California attorney general in 2010, Kamala Devi Harris and her team have been busy tackling issues as wide-ranging as truancy, transnational gangs, Medi-Cal recovery and mortgage fraud in a state so large that she sometimes flies six planes a week to cover it all—from her air-conditioned Sacramento offices to the air-conditioned tunnels in Calexico designed for trafficking guns, drugs and humans under the border.

  • Support/Volunteer Opportunities

    The following numbers can be contacted for drug and alcohol assistance. 

    Alcoholics Anonymous (323) 936-4343 
    Cocaine Anonymous (310) 216-4444 
    Narcotics Anonymous (323) 933-5395 
     
    LA Treatment Facilities          
     
    AV Treatment Facilities