Ethics panel to rule on fraudulent campaign contributions to Villaraigosa’s 2009 campaign
Koreatown real estate developer
LOS ANGELES, Calif.—The city Ethics Commission is expected to decide tomorrow if a prominent Koreatown real estate developer illegally laundered $18,000 for Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s 2009 reelection campaign.
CIC Group Chief Executive Officer Alexander Hugh is accused ofillegally making contributions in June 2008 under “assumed names” and exceeding the maximum $1,000 contribution to the campaign of a candidate for citywide office.
Hugh pleaded not guilty in April to five felony counts filed by Los Angeles County District Attorney Steve Cooley, including conspiracy to commit campaign money laundering, two counts of filing false documents, forgery and false personation.
The city Ethics Commission alleges Hugh worked with his longtime friend Annette Lee to have employees of her escrow firm give $1,000 contributions to Villaraigosa’s campaign. Hugh then allegedly reimbursed the employees, which is illegal.
Hugh also contributed $1,000 to the campaign in his own name.
The year before the alleged money laundering occurred, Hugh won approval from the City Council and Villaraigosa for a large hotel project, despite a lack of support for the hotel from Villaraigosa’s own Planning Commission appointees. The commission was concerned that the hotel, which was never built, would overwhelm the surrounding neighborhood.
A spokesman for Villaraigosa declined to comment.
The city Ethics Commission charged Hugh with 18 counts of making contributions under assumed names and two counts of illegally exceeding campaign contribution limits. He faces a maximum penalty of $183,750.
Hugh agreed not to dispute the facts of the case and waived his right to an investigation by the commission, but he declined to admit guilt.
Hugh’s attorney submitted a brief asking the commission to consider issuing a much lower penalty.
“We hope the commission, in light of what is in effect a no-contest plea, will come to a reasonable and equitable penalty,” said Hugh’s attorney, Kenneth White.
He declined to name a fair penalty amount.
In a brief filed with the commission, White wrote that Hugh had no record of violating election laws and said he worked quickly to cooperate with the commission, saving the panel “substantial effort and resources” to prove its case.
White painted Hugh as a man in his mid-60s whose retirement would include volunteer work through his church, including trips to help rebuild earthquake-ravaged Japan and parts of Vietnam. Hugh’s retirement plans would be crippled by a large fine, his attorney argued.
White said Hugh contributed greatly to the Koreatown neighborhood through real estate developments that generated jobs and tax revenue. He declined to comment on the facts of the case, including what those real estate developments were.
He said Hugh is likely to be adequately punished by the criminal case pending in Los Angeles County Superior Court and would not be able to afford the maximum fine issued by the commission. He cited a negative settlement against Hugh in a prior employment case, the legal fees in the pending election law cases and Hugh’s lack of income because of the anemic real estate industry.
“Mr. Hugh’s involvement in political contributions does not reflect an effort to influence politicians,” White wrote. “Rather, Mr. Hugh’s political activity was directed to favor politicians who promoted development in Koreatown and took that development seriously.”
City Ethics Commission staff were not swayed by the arguments for keeping the penalty low. In a memo, Ethics Commission Director of Enforcement Deena Ghaly recommended a penalty near the maximum. She said political money laundering charges are “among the most serious of the transgressions the Commission enforces against, because they undermine the public’s important interests in limiting campaign contributions and knowing the sources of contributions.”
Despite cooperating with the commission, Ghaly said, Hugh still refuses to admit guilt. She said Hugh failed to show any proof the penalty would ruin him economically, and the commission is not required to consider that argument when weighing his penalty.
Finally, Ghaly said, the alleged crimes required premeditation.
“These are serious violations involving actions of both concealment and deceit and constituting a pattern, rather than an isolated incident, of wrongdoing,” she wrote.
LOS ANGELES, Calif.—The city Ethics Commission today found one of Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s re-election campaign donors guilty of money laundering and fined him $183,750 for violating campaign finance laws.
The fine for real estate executive Alexander Hugh, the head of CIC Group, was the maximum under city law.
The commission voted 4-0 to support the case presented by investigators, who found Hugh illegally made $18,000 in contributions in June 2008 under “assumed names” and exceeding the limit of $1,000.
LOS ANGELES, Calif. — A father and son are expected to be sentenced to federal prison terms today for their roles in the illegal trafficking of South African rhinoceros horns in a case brought as part of a nationwide crackdown on the black market in endangered animal parts.
LOS ANGELES, Calif. — The publisher of a southeast Los Angeles weekly newspaper filed two complaints today accusing City Controller and mayoral candidate Wendy Greuel of misusing city resources for campaign purposes.
Brian Hews of Los Cerritos Community Newspaper submitted letters to the District Attorney’s Office and the city Ethics Commission, requesting investigations into Greuel’s city emails that he claims have been used to further her mayoral campaign.
LOS ANGELES, Calif. — Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa is expected to highlight his eight years in office — particularly in the areas of public safety, education, business, transportation and the environment — when he delivers his final “state of the city” address this afternoon.
LOS ANGELES, Calif.—Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa will be joined today by Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel and Mayor Cory Booker of Newark, N.J., in a discussion at the Los Angeles Convention Center on the challenges of urban education reform.
Villaraigosa will also be honored at the United Way of Greater Los Angeles’ 2013 Education Summit for championing education reform. Although the mayor of Los Angeles has no formal role in education, Villaraigosa has made education one of his priorities since taking office in 2005.